- The Knowledge
- Posts
- Yuval Noah Harari on Gaza
Yuval Noah Harari on Gaza
đ Moon train | đ¸ Shuttlecock football | đââď¸ No shampoo
In the headlines
Thousands of women born in the 1950s should be given compensation because the government failed to tell them about changes to the state pension age, an official report has concluded. A parliamentary watchdog says so-called âWaspiâ women, who were caught out when the threshold rose from 60 to 65, should be entitled to up to ÂŁ2,950 each. An AI tool has spotted early signs of breast cancer that were missed by doctors, says BBC News. The technology analysed more than 10,000 NHS mammograms and successfully flagged all the cases the humans had spotted â as well as 11 they hadnât. A Polish tree nicknamed âHeart of the Gardenâ has been crowned European Tree of the Year. The common beech in the University of WrocĹawâs botanical garden pipped others including Weeping Beech of Bayeux in Normandy; Sardiniaâs Olive Tree of Luras, thought to be up to 4,000 years old; and a sweet chestnut in Wrexham. For more top trees, click here.
Comment
Maggie Thatcher and Rachel Reeves. Getty
Labourâs Thatcher tribute act
When news broke this week that shadow chancellor Rachel Reeves was going to make a speech to city bigwigs promising to be as radical as Margaret Thatcher, says Phil Tinline in The New Statesman, âit was no surprise that cries of outrage followedâ. There is no modern politician more lionised by the British right, or more loathed by the left. But it was a canny move. Reeves and Keir Starmer know that while the Corbynistas may howl, they have no other party to vote for, and that wavering, business-minded former Tories might be persuadable. And she did a fine job, promising to âfashion a new economic settlementâ, just as Thatcher had done at the end of the grim 1970s. She vowed to âdrive innovationâ and âmobilise investmentâ to foster much-needed growth, while putting the economic security of ordinary working people first. The only question now is whether she can muster âsomething of Thatcherâs steelâ.
Sorry, but is anyone listening to what sheâs actually saying, asks John Rentoul in The Independent. Itâs nonsense â a âjumble of contradictory signallingâ that conceals âthin policiesâ and a âdesperate attempt to play it safeâ. This is the sort of âpresentational trickâ you can only get away with when your party is 20 points ahead in the polls, and when even the Tory press is âlooking forward to a change of governmentâ. If the two parties were neck and neck, perhaps more commentators would be asking whether Reevesâs trademark âsecuronomicsâ means anything. The central theme of her lecture â boosting the economy â amounted to little more than a Liz Truss-style âdash for growthâ, hopefully without the market meltdown. Could it be that her âblizzard of words and channelling Maggieâ are ways of hiding the fact that she has no real plan?
Photography
Smithsonian Magazine has announced the 60 finalists in its annual photo competition, whittled down from more than 30,000 entries. They include shots of four cheetah cubs resting by their mother in Kenya; a Huli Wigman in Papua New Guinea; a boat packed with colourfully-clothed passengers in Bangladesh; a secretarybird chomping down on a lizard in Botswana; and three bull moose in Americaâs Rocky Mountains. See the rest here.
Tomorrowâs world
The US has asked the aerospace firm Northrup Grumman to see if it can figure out how to build a railway on the moon, says Quartz. The idea, dreamt up by the governmentâs cutting-edge tech department Darpa, is to kick-start the transport infrastructure needed to create a âlunar economyâ, which the consultancy PwC believes could be worth $170bn by 2040. Separately, Japanese researchers have proposed an interplanetary transport system called the Hexatrack, which would allow passengers to take a bullet train to the moon, though thatâs rather more speculative.
Sport
Jianzi is a traditional Chinese sport similar to badminton, but with a heavily weighted shuttlecock and no rackets. Players have to get the projectile back over the net and into the court using any part of their body â except their hands. Watch a longer clip here.
Comment
Israeli troops near the southern Gaza border in October. Jack Guez/AFP/Getty
The tragedy of Gaza: both sides are being ârationalâ
Many people see the seemingly intractable differences between the Israelis and the Palestinians as âirrationalâ, says Yuval Noah Harari in the FT. In fact, theyâre anything but. For the Palestinians, the âfounding eventâ of their modern identity is the 1948 Nakba, when the nascent state of Israel drove 750,000 of their people out of their ancestral homes. In the decades since, Palestinians have suffered ârepeated massacres and expulsionsâ at the hands of Israel and other regional powers. Their perfectly rational fear is that, were it not for the international community, Israel would seek to âexpel most or all of themâ and establish a Jewish-only country. Numerous politicians and parties, including Benjamin Netanyahuâs Likud, have openly talked of creating âGreater Israelâ â the expansion of settlements in the West Bank is viewed as part of this âabiding wishâ.
For the Israelis, of course, the founding event of their modern identity was the murder of six million Jews in the Holocaust. In 1948, the Palestinians and their Arab allies sought to âannihilateâ their new country; when those and subsequent efforts failed (in 1956 and 1967), Arab nations took revenge by driving 800,000 Jews out of their ancestral homes in countries such as Egypt, Iraq and Syria. âAt least half of Israeli Jews are the descendants of these Middle Eastern refugees.â The Israelisâ perfectly rational fear is that the Palestinians would happily kill or expel them all â as their leaders have repeatedly advocated. The two sides, in short, both have good reason to believe that the other lot are an âexistential threatâ. Their decades-long impasse is the result not of âunjustified paranoiaâ, but of âa sound analysis of the situationâ.
Life
Ryan Weideman/Bruce Silverstein Gallery
When aspiring photographer Ryan Weideman moved from California to New York in 1980, says My Modern Met, he began driving a taxi on the weekends and taking pictures of his passengers. Sometimes he asked for permission; other times the flash âaccidentallyâ went off. âThe backseat image was constantly in a state of flux,â says Weideman, âthronged with interesting looking people that were exciting and inspired, creating their own unique atmosphere.â See more of his photos here.
Zeitgeist
The #noshampoo movement â in which people indefinitely stop washing their hair with soap â is taking off on TikTok, especially among teenage boys. Good on them, says Matthew Parris in The Times. If you stop shampooing and start rinsing your hair thoroughly with warm water once a day, it will âgrease up for a couple of weeksâ before re-establishing the natural balance found in every other mammal âfrom poodles to rabbits to polar bearsâ. I havenât washed my hair in 30 years and Iâm âfluffy as a kittenâ â at 74, my hair is my best feature.
Snapshot
Snapshot answer
Itâs the largest golden nugget ever discovered in England, says The Guardian. The treasure was unearthed in the Shropshire Hills last year by veteran detectorist Richard Brock. It was a particularly serendipitous discovery: the 67-year-old had turned up to the organised expedition an hour late, and was using an older, faulty metal detector because his normal kit wasnât working. The so-called âHiroâs Nuggetâ weighs 64.8g, smashing the previous record of 54g, and is expected to fetch at least ÂŁ30,000 at auction.
Quoted
âAnyone enquiring: âDo you know who I am?â is effectively asking: âDo you know who I was?ââ
Marina Hyde