The real reason China won’t give up TikTok

👴 Plucky pensioner | 🍍 £100 pizza | 🎬 Bob Dylan biopic

Comment

A recent protest in Washington DC. Brendan Smialowski/AFP/Getty

The real reason China won’t give up TikTok

What many people don’t realise about America’s so-called “TikTok ban” is that it isn’t a ban at all, says Noah Smith on Substack. Congress has demanded that the app’s Chinese owner, ByteDance, sell up to a non-Chinese buyer, but ByteDance doesn’t want to sell. The obvious question is: why not? They know they could get “untold billions” for it, and when the US government made the same demand of the Chinese-owned gay dating app Grindr back in 2020, Beijing “put up little fuss” and the owners sold up. The answer is simple: China’s leaders consider TikTok so important they’d “rather destroy it than see it escape their control”.

Some supporters of the divestiture bill say TikTok has been secretly transferring Americans’ personal data to the Chinese government; others are worried about its social harms. But the big issue is propaganda. There’s already strong evidence that TikTok conceals content critical of China and amplifies narratives that align with Beijing’s aims. If the app stays in Chinese hands, it could potentially be weaponised to dangerously stoke America’s racial and partisan divisions. And Beijing’s approach to TikTok has to be considered in the context of all its other “aggressive, sinister” activities: preparing for war in Taiwan, hacking into critical US infrastructure, and so on. This is a concerted effort to “weaken and compromise” America – the only country capable of putting up a serious fight against Chinese global hegemony – in every sphere of commerce and influence. The US can either resist that push, or “knuckle under and accept a poorer, more divided nation”.

Property

THE WAREHOUSE This three-bedroom loft apartment is spread across the top two levels of a former warehouse in Camberwell, south London. The first floor comprises a large open-plan kitchen and living area. Also on this floor are two bedrooms, one of which has an en-suite shower room, and a family bathroom. The main bedroom is on the upper level, with access to a glass-encased roof terrace. Denmark Hill train station is a 15-minute walk. £1.55m.

Heroes and villains

Hero
Ron Croker, a pensioner in South Yorkshire who fought off a robber with a pair of freshly washed jeans. The 84-year-old was in Coin-Op Laundry in Maltby when a masked man burst in and demanded his wallet. Croker refused and shouted back, pushing the mugger out of the shop. When his assailant came back in and tried to grab Croker’s belongings, the outraged OAP swung his folded-up jeans into the man’s face and forced him out for a second time. “He just picked on the wrong bloke,” he tells The Times. “It was either me or him and I won.”

Villains
The Glasgow International Comedy Festival, for insisting that all its performers agree to a code of conduct prohibiting “discriminatory or harmful” views and insisting that all material is performed “without malicious intent”. God only knows what gags will actually be allowed, says Michael Deacon in The Daily Telegraph. “Why did the chicken cross the road? To join a mass protest against the apartheid state of Israel’s genocide of the people of occupied Gaza.”

Villains
People who like pineapple on their pizza, according to a fancy pizzeria in Norfolk that is charging £100 for a Hawaiian to deter people from ordering it. Francis Woolf, co-owner of Lupa Pizza in Norwich, says he begrudgingly added the dish to the restaurant’s Deliveroo menu after receiving several requests from customers, but increased the price after his team took exception to sullying their pizzas with pineapple. “Never,” says head chef Quin Jianoran. “I’d rather put a bloody strawberry on one than that tropical menace.”

New York Post/ABC News

Villain
David Muir, the notoriously vain star anchor for ABC News in the US, who has been mocked for using clothes pegs to cinch in an unflattering flame-retardant jacket while reporting on the Los Angeles fires. “Glad you look nice and svelte,” wrote TV producer Jack Osbourne on X, “while our city burns to the ground.”

Villains
The Scottish government, which wants to ban birthday cakes in nurseries. Ministers say the rules are necessary to address rising obesity rates, and suggest a “special activity” or a “special trip” as alternative forms of celebration.

Enjoying The Knowledge?
Click below to share

What to watch

Timothée Chalamet as Bob Dylan. Searchlight Pictures

A Complete Unknown, which charts Bob Dylan’s rise to stardom in the 1960s, is a dream, says Robbie Collin in The Daily Telegraph. As accessible to newcomers as it is rewarding for die-hards, the whole thing is “gorgeously tactile” and wonderfully free of clichés. Timothée Chalamet delivers a “rivetingly lived-in” central performance as Dylan, miraculously embodying the young star’s “once-in-a-generation coolness, genius and truculence”. If there’s anything wrong with his singing voice, it’s perhaps that it’s “slightly too good”. Other standouts include Edward Norton as Dylan’s sometime-mentor Pete Seeger, and Monica Barbaro’s “duskily charismatic” Joan Baez. Maybe Dylan is too “mercurial a figure for a biopic to ever capture him completely”, but this “gorgeous film comes as close as you could hope”.

Comment

Are retirees democracy’s real winners? Getty

The young are right: their votes don’t count

One in five voters under the age of 45 would prefer to do away with democracy and instead have an authoritarian strongman govern Britain, says Stephen Daisley in The Spectator. These findings come from the as-yet-unpublished FGS Global Radar report, but the data is consistent with previous findings: a 2020 study found that millennials grow less satisfied with democracy each year. Why are the youth suddenly in revolt against our form of government? Some point to “reactionary and authoritarian instincts” among very online young men; others say it’s an ultra-progressive response to the electoral success of figures they despise, like Donald Trump. Or perhaps it’s a backlash against that very progressivism, signalling the growth of a “right-wing counter-elite”.

I think the answer is far simpler: it’s the economy, stupid. Just 37% of those born in the 1980s owned a home by age 30, compared to 62% of those born in the 1960s. An average house in England costs 8.6 times the average annual income, up from 4.4 times in 1999. Housing developments are blocked by retired homeowners whose pensions the young are being taxed to death to pay for. Previous generations could try their luck abroad, but since Brexit, which the young voted against, they no longer have access to the world’s largest labour market. Earning power and social mobility are going backwards; even the most basic hallmarks of middle-class British life – buying a house, starting a family – are beyond much of the youth. Is it any wonder 30% of Brits aged 25 to 34 say “voting doesn’t make any difference”? After all, they’re right.

Weather

Quoted

“Some minds are like soup in a poor restaurant – better left unstirred.”
PG Wodehouse

That’s it. You’re done.

Let us know what you thought of today’s issue by replying to this email
To find out about advertising and partnerships, click here
Been forwarded this newsletter? Try it for free
Enjoying The Knowledge? Click to share

Reply

or to participate.